Nov 19, 2026

Ohio Agrees to $10.2 Million in Settlements for Five Wrongfully Imprisoned Men


Ohio Agrees to $10.2 Million in Settlements for Five Wrongfully Imprisoned Men

TOLEDO, Ohio — Ohio has agreed to settlements totaling $10.2 million for five men whose convictions in a 1992 Toledo killing were overturned. The agreements still require approval before becoming final, according to court documents reported by WTVG.

Lucas County judges declared Eric Misch, Louis Costilla Jr., Joseph Rickard and brothers Ismael “Mel” Vasquez and Lorenzo Vasquez wrongfully imprisoned in connection with the killing of Vernon Huggins.

Misch, Costilla and Rickard would each receive $2.9 million. The Vasquez brothers would receive $750,000 each. Ismael Vasquez spent 32 years in prison, while Lorenzo Vasquez spent 22 years behind bars.

According to reporting from WTOL-TV and the Ohio News Network, Lucas County Prosecutor Julia Bates said her office learned that police records had never reached prosecutors or defense attorneys. Missing evidence and other problems with the case led prosecutors to seek dismissal of the charges.


Severe Weather Alert